r/CatastrophicFailure • • Sep 11 '17

Meta Posting Guidelines - Read Before Submitting

692 Upvotes

Posting Rules

1. No jokes/memes

If your post is a joke or meme, it does not belong here. This includes posts about politicians, celebrities, movies or products that flopped, bad business/PR decisions, countries in turmoil, etc.

2. Titles

Titles must only be informative and descriptive (who, what, where, when, why) not editorialized ("I bet he lost his job!") - do not include personal opinions or other commentary in your titles.

Examples of bad titles:

  • I don't know if this belongs here, but it's cool! (x-post r/funny)

  • What could go wrong?

  • Building Failure

A good title reads like a newspaper headline, or Wikipedia article. If you don't know the specifics about the failure, then describe the events that take place in the video/image instead. Examples of good titles:

If it is a cross-post you should post that as a comment and not part of the title

3. Mundane Failures

Avoid posting mundane, everyday occurences like car crashes unless there is something spectacular about your submission. Nearly 1.3 million people die in road crashes each year, and there are many other subreddits already dedicated to this topic such as r/dashcam, r/racecrashes, and /r/carcrash

While there are some examples of extraordinary crashes posted here, in general they would probably be better suited for those other subreddits:

4. Compilations

Compilations and montages are not allowed on r/CatastrophicFailure. Any video that is a collection of clips from multiple incidents, including top 10 lists are considered compilations.
If your submission contains footage of one incident but compiled from multiple sources or angles, those are fine to post.

5. Be Respectful

Always be respectful in the comments section of a thread, especially if people were injured or killed.

6. Objects, Not People

The focus of this subreddit is on machines, buildings, or objects breaking, not people breaking. If the only notable thing in your submission is injury/death, it probably would go better in another subreddit.

Flair Rules

All posts should have an appropriate flair applied to them by the submitter, please follow these 4 steps to determine if your thread needs a fatality/injury flair. You can set this by clicking the "flair" button under the title of your submission.

  1. If your submission depicts people dying, you must apply the "Visible Fatalities" flair to your post and tag it "NSFW"
  2. If your submission depicts people visibly being seriously injured, you must apply the "Visible Injuries" flair to your post and tag it "NSFW"
  3. If your submission depicts a situation where people were killed, but those people are not directly visible you must apply the "Fatalities" flair to your post (eg. the Hindenburg Disaster, or a plane crash)
  4. If your submission does not require one of those tags, you should pick any of the other flairs to describe what type of failure occurred

r/CatastrophicFailure • • 8h ago

Fire/Explosion Chemical plant burning right now in Szeged, Hungary

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

142 Upvotes

r/CatastrophicFailure • • 1d ago

Natural Disaster White River - Quarry Flood - August 2026

Thumbnail
youtu.be
279 Upvotes

r/CatastrophicFailure • • 1d ago

USCSB - 2022 BP Husky Refinery fire

Thumbnail
youtu.be
94 Upvotes

r/CatastrophicFailure • • 2d ago

Operator jumps from crane cab as the large machine wildly topples. Date and location unknown.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2.1k Upvotes

r/CatastrophicFailure • • 2d ago

Fatalities Picture of the wreckage of Gol Transportes Aéreos Flight 1907. 20 years ago today, on September 29, 2006, it collided in mid-air with an Embraer 600 business jet over Brazil. More details in comments.

Post image
231 Upvotes

r/CatastrophicFailure • • 2d ago

Different angle of the landslide in Nepal yesterday 🇳🇵

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2.0k Upvotes

r/CatastrophicFailure • • 3d ago

Massive Landslide in Nepal 09/28/2026

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2.2k Upvotes

r/CatastrophicFailure • • 1d ago

Engineering Failure (1967) Silver Bridge collapse, Point Pleasant, West Virginia — failure of a cracked eyebar led to progressive collapse

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

The Silver Bridge used an eyebar-chain suspension system with very little redundancy. On December 15, 1967, failure originating in a single eyebar triggered a chain of structural failures and the bridge collapsed into the Ohio River.

This breakdown focuses on the tiny defect, the load path and why one failed component was able to bring down the entire structure.


r/CatastrophicFailure • • 2d ago

Fire/Explosion Today Switzerland (Neuchâtel) around 12 - 1pm

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

A floor imploded around 12 to 1 p.m., leaving several people injured, at least one of whom was taken to the emergency room. It was probably a gas explosion that blew out from the inside, and the building was still inhabited even though part of it had been under renovation for several months.


r/CatastrophicFailure • • 4d ago

Plastics factory on fire, South Haven, Michigan (US) 9-26-26

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2.4k Upvotes

r/CatastrophicFailure • • 5d ago

MULTIPLE incompetent crane operators (2026)

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.0k Upvotes

r/CatastrophicFailure • • 6d ago

Natural Disaster A massive landslide tears through Seyðisfjörður, Iceland – December 2020

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

322 Upvotes

r/CatastrophicFailure • • 7d ago

Equipment Failure A 3-engine 62-car CN Railway freight train from Vancouver transporting livestock partly derailed near North York, Ontario. Three crew were injured and some of the livestock onboard was killed, badly injured, or escaped. (Sept. 23, 1962)

Thumbnail
gallery
282 Upvotes

The train derailed near Oriole Station because of a switch that was not only misaligned, but also left open. After an investigation, the cause was determined to be local kids messing around with it.

Among CN Railway No. 302 freight cargo was approximately 50 horses and 200 cows. The animals in the derailed stock cars were either killed on impact, injured and had to be euthanized by police, or escaped the crashed train uninjured and fled.


r/CatastrophicFailure • • 7d ago

Structural Failure Kielland Platform March 27, 1980

Thumbnail
gallery
656 Upvotes

Offshore drilling expanded greatly in the 1970s. At the time, Mobile Offshore Drilling Units (MODUs) totalled approx. 390 vessels split between Jackups, Drillships, and Semi-Submersibles. The Alexander L. Kielland platform was built by the French Compagnie Française d'Entreprises Métalliques at their shipyard in Dunkirk, France, with final delivery of the five column Semisub completed in 1976. In the North Sea on March 27, 1980 there were 212 men aboard in 12m seas when a loud crack and rumble were heard.

The Kielland began to list 30 degrees, and within 20 minutes it capsized. A horizontal bracing member D-6, below the waterline, had parted. This was not the location of a heavily loaded girth weld. Rather, a fatigue crack started at a small poorly-prepared 6mm fillet weld which held a non-load-bearing hydrophone flange. This hydrophone, used for dynamic positioning, wasn’t even in use as the platform was then moored.

CAUSES: Few men made it to lifeboats, but many lifeboats failed to release due

to complications from the listing and/or faulty release mechanisms. 123 men died. Poor welding and inspection practice allowed a small initial flaw in the weld/plate to grow over time with cyclic loading. Structural design did not allow for damage tolerance or anticipate the loss of an entire column. Regular insitu structural inspections focused on the vertical columns and largely ignored the horizontal members below the waterline.

Some more details on engineering gaps, missed signs, and failed safeguards:

  1. The weld joined a non-load-bearing flange plate (meant for a sonar hydrophone) to the D-6 lower horizontal tubular bracing.

  2. The 6mm fillet weld suffered from a bad geometric profile, lack of fusion, and poor inspection during fabrication at the French shipyard. Investigators found paint -IN- the crack, meaning it was there before the hull was painted. Because it was considered a superficial addition, it was not carefully inspected.

  3. The area experienced cracking in the structural steel alongside lamellar tearing (midplane delamination)

  4. Under constant cyclic loading from rough North Sea waves, the pre-existing flaw in the weld grew slowly, undetected, over 4 years to approximately half the circumference before rapid failure that March.

  5. The crack eventually severed the D-6 brace entirely. The structure wasn’t designed to survive or prevent the cascading effect of the loss of one member (little redundancy). The remaining connected braces overloaded and failed, causing one of the five main structural columns to rip away in moments, capsizing the structure in a few minutes.

  6. Out of 5x 50man lifeboats, only one launched properly; “safety”mechanisms prevented the others from releasing while under heavy cable strain, or they smashed against the listing hull. A second boat broke free after the platform capsized, providing some shelter for men in the water. Regulations changed soon after to mandate excess lifeboat capacity and on-load releasing mechanisms.

  7. Inadequate or confused emergency command structure.

  8. Survival gear shortages. Some of the workers died after jumping into the water due to hypothermia. Cold water “Gumby” suits were not mandatory at the time, but are now for North Sea, Canadian, and other cold water operating areas.


r/CatastrophicFailure • • 8d ago

Fire/Explosion On 23 September 2026, an RAF Hawk T2, a two-seat advanced jet trainer, crashed near RAF Valley in Wales. Both crew ejected and were taken for treatment. Emergency services responded, and an investigation is underway.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2.7k Upvotes

r/CatastrophicFailure • • 7d ago

Fire/Explosion 23/09/2026 RAF Hawk T2 take off run, aircraft subsequently crashed with both crew ejecting

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

351 Upvotes

r/CatastrophicFailure • • 9d ago

Natural Disaster Landslide caused by a typhoon damages Road and cuts power in Ochi Town, Chiba Prefecture, Japan. 21st September 2026

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.1k Upvotes

r/CatastrophicFailure • • 11d ago

Operator Error Crew members film the moment the Panama-flagged bulk carrier First Margaux collides with the Chinese fishing vessel Luqing Yuanyu 108 near Singapore. September 20, 2026

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

5.1k Upvotes

r/CatastrophicFailure • • 12d ago

Fire/Explosion Piper Alpha July 6, 1988

Thumbnail
gallery
1.0k Upvotes

I think most readers here know this story. The Pipe Alpha was a gas platform in the North Sea. A series of errors lead to it's destruction and 167 deaths. It was designed primarily to handle oil when it was new, but at the time of the incident it was processing and exporting a lot of gas from wells in its own drill center (~33 million cubic feet per day) plus that from several nearby fields.

Maintenance took a Condensate Pump A offline along with removing its relieve valve to make some planned repair. They capped the position of the relief valve with a blind flange that wasn't designed for full rated pressure and it wasn't pressure tested. On the next shift, Condensate Pump B tripped offline and the crew mistakenly switched production back over to Pump A whereby the blind flange at the relief valve position ruptures and gas (mostly propane) escaped eventually finding an ignition source.

It was hard to put together the root causes. Most of the physical evidence burnt down and sank along with the platform, and most field supervisors and management died on location. But investigators best guess is what is described above and below.

Safeguards Missing:

  1. Lockout-tagout for Pump A.
  2. Permit related to missing relief valve and Pump A shutdown not communicated to the next shift.
  3. Flange not tested, not rated for RWP of the line.
  4. Immediate shut-in of incoming gas lines (ESD, Emergency Shut Down). When the fire had started, operators hesitated to shut down incoming gas from other fields due to fear of disrupting production.
  5. Emergency procedures sufficient to cover fires, explosion, and evacuation for scenarios like this.

More discussion here (not my article).
https://www.thechemicalengineer.com/features/piper-alpha-the-disaster-in-detail/

I'm an engineer and spend to decent amount of time thinking about safety systems, what-ifs, root causes, and how to prevent stuff like this. I have a couple projects I'm working on to help other people in these lines of work learn from history like this. Check bio.

A lot of what I see in the subreddit highlights the visual element and most are pretty recent, viewed here without the benefit of investigation reports and hard facts about the causes. Many seem self-evident but the gap something I think about.

Many of the biggest engineering disasters contain recurring root causes. Normalization of Deviation (ignored or missed warnings), Poor management of change (MOC), safety systems degraded or removed, lack of regulatory controls.


r/CatastrophicFailure • • 13d ago

Fatalities On January 13th 1969, Scandinavian Airlines flight 933 crashes into Santa Monica Bay after the flight crew became preoccupied with determining whether or not the nose gear was down, killing 15 of the 45 passengers and crew onboard (More in article below)

Post image
918 Upvotes

r/CatastrophicFailure • • 12d ago

Operator Error Lt. Cmdr. M. W. McMahon crash lands his SBC-3 aircraft into the deck of the USS Saratoga on March 19 (1938)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
66 Upvotes

r/CatastrophicFailure • • 15d ago

Fatalities Helicopter crashes while reporting on a bus crash below. Near Los Angeles 9-15-26

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

8.6k Upvotes

View and sounds from inside a NBC/Telemundo news helicopter as it reports on a deadly bus crash on the streets below. Reports of one death in the helicopter. Happened about an hour ago in the San Fernando Valley near Los Angeles.

UPDATE: https://ktla.com/news/local-news/helicopter-crashes-near-deadly-l-a-metro-bus-crash/


r/CatastrophicFailure • • 16d ago

Fatalities Ammonia Gas Leak at the Southern Fertiliser Company in Basra Iraq (September 13, 2026) Two workers dead, up to 114 injured

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2.3k Upvotes

On Sunday, September 13, 2026, an accidental ammonia gas leak occurred at the State Company of Southern Fertilizers in the Khor Al-Zubair industrial area of Basra Province, Iraq. Civil Defense teams — including a CBRN response unit — rescued 10 employees trapped inside the facility and recovered the bodies of two workers who died from severe gas exposure: one from the plant's precision-instruments department, the other from its compressor section. Both died in hospital despite resuscitation attempts.

The Ministry of Health reported the injury toll climbing through the day, ultimately reaching approximately 90-114 people.

Authorities confirmed the toxic plume extended beyond the facility boundary into nearby residential areas, affecting local residents alongside plant workers. The cause of the leak has not yet been determined. https://www.facebook.com/share/v/19SnHjjMU3/