r/TopCharacterTropes • u/Mysral • Aug 22 '26
miscellaneous A normally silly trope is instead played for complete seriousness, and is all the more effective for it.
* The Legend of Korra: The villain tying someone to a railway track is one of the deadest horses in all of fiction, almost exclusively the domain of mustache-twirling cartoon scoundrels. When Kuvira does it to a gang of captured bandits, however, it comes across as entirely realistic - and profoundly terrifying. Which, let's face it, being chained in the path of a speeding maglev would be.
* Spider-Man - Homecoming: Adrian Toomes gets a rare live-action lightbulb moment when the reflection of a green traffic light on his face symbolizes his realization who "good old Spider-Man" actually is. It enhances, rather than undercuts, the tension of the scene.
* Star Wars - Revenge of the Sith: Anakin screaming "I hate you!" to Obi-Wan at the top of his lungs - normally a line reserved for a child's tantrum against a parent - is instead an agonizing gut-punch at the climax of an already tragic scene.
8.1k
u/LouisGustavo Aug 22 '26
2.9k
246
u/ballistic503 Aug 22 '26
Good mention, that frame still gives me goosebumps, but I would really argue this is a subversion of a trope rather than one played straight. The trope is “lengthy monologue about villainous plan so hero can stop it” and the subversion is that it turns out that the heroes can’t stop it. I personally don’t think that’s playing it straight
→ More replies (1)1.9k
u/KingOfThePlayPlace Aug 22 '26
I read the first two bubbles and thought “yeah right, that’s what they all say” and the then I read the third bubble and went “oh, yeah, that’s changes thing a little”
→ More replies (5)216
u/madog1418 Aug 22 '26
I just love how it’s by itself on the opposite corner of the panel, so you A) put a natural pause there, and B) will completely read the first bubbles without so much as glancing at the last bubble.
120
u/mrwynd Aug 23 '26
I think this is one of those things a lot of internet comics fail at so it feels like a lost art.
80
u/caitlindrawings Aug 23 '26
Even in comics this was a rare art, not all comic arts were good at bubble placement like this.
30
u/Tyranis_Hex Aug 23 '26
The paneling and layout of Watchmen is itself a master work.
→ More replies (1)1.0k
u/SaintGrobian Aug 22 '26
I hated how the movie did this - "I triggered it 35 minutes ago", and then it cuts to it seemingly happening in real time, as if the process took 35 minutes to overload or charge or whatever.
In the comics, it's done. They're 35 minutes late to the party. Check mate has already been accomplished, the credits are over. Nothing is simultaneously happening on the other side of the world, the smoke has already cleared, because they simply didn't figure it out in time. It's not that they can't stop it and can only powerlessly look on - it already happened while they were fucking about. They were never the heroes of the story, they missed it completely.
So much more bleak.
470
u/Vjornaxx Aug 22 '26 edited Aug 22 '26
They actually show it happening when they arrive and start to make their way towards the hideout.
When they pull out for the establishing shot and All Along the Watchtower is playing, Ozy’s hideout can be seen with blue light in the windows. Then it gets brighter, flashes, and you hear the machine doing its thing.
The flashback shows what was happening during that establishing shot.
I remember catching that detail in the theater and thought it was pretty slick.
103
u/7_Constanza Aug 22 '26
The original comment has 712 likes . Tells you that people just unnecessarily hate the movie over something they misunderstood
29
u/ManajaTwa18 Aug 22 '26
The way Moore wrote it is more elegant but the comic and film come to the same conclusion. It’s really just nitpicking to complain about the latter lmao
→ More replies (10)20
u/theLanguageSprite2 Aug 23 '26
I only hate on the movie because they removed my favorite character, the genetically engineered teleporting psychic squid alien
→ More replies (2)281
u/stinkingyeti Aug 22 '26
It still works in the movie, one can make the assumption that it was a chain reaction that just took time.
Or, the movie is just showing us what has happened, what the plan was.
86
u/Prince_Habib_72 Aug 22 '26
The movie has a lot of problems, but this isn't one of them.
In the graphic novel, there's only one attack- a giant squid monster in NYC whose death triggers a psychic bomb, killing everyone in NYC. It's triggered 35 minutes prior, and the squid is already there and dead when Ozymandias gives his speech (which notably includes "I did it thirty-five minutes ago", implying a single event). The idea is that humanity must band together to fight off an invasion from another dimension.
In the film, there are many attacks on many cities, using Doctor Manhattan's energy signature to vaporize a dozen cities around the world. When the film runs from Ozymandias to the monitors, you can see every city except New York has already been destroyed, and it's in the final seconds of the countdown. His speech this time includes the phrase "I triggered it thirty-five minutes ago", implying a series of events. It's not a flashback, or implying that it is all happening at the same time. We just see the last attack to happen out of a series.
→ More replies (3)522
u/Cuniving Aug 22 '26
You do realise its not actually simultaenously happening right? Its just showing us what happened 35 minutes ago? I think most people understood that and that it was a cool way of us getting to see what happened, which is more important in a movie. I think pretty universally audiences would have been left feeling kinda underwhelmed and maybe even a little cheated if it just cut to generically cratered city instead of showing us what happened.
285
u/Nebulo9 Aug 22 '26
.....honestly, cutting to a cratered New York City directly after that speech might go hard as hell if done right. Like, no big awesome spectacle or comicbook cgi fest, just the brutal horror of the act and its consequences.
101
u/SeraphymCrashing Aug 22 '26
I agree.
I mean, I liked the scene in the movie, but I think just a cut to a devasted city would have actually gone harder.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)97
u/SaintGrobian Aug 22 '26
"U do realize" that when Rorschach and Nite-Owl sneak up on Ozymandias, he's watching a wall of televisions and not a single one mentions anything, right? No chaos, no confusion, no catastrophe, right?
The process took 35 minutes, and happens right as they arrive.
63
u/AmputeeDoug Aug 22 '26
I havent seen the movie in a while and i might be a little fuzzy on the details but, I always took that scene to be Ozy reminiscing on the world he destroyed, he even says he made himself feel every life he ruined not him watching the news waiting for people to react to the bomb. One thing I'm kinda bummed the movie changed was the giant squid monster
→ More replies (1)52
u/jango-got-chained Aug 22 '26
Did you know in old movies they had to show the wheels of a car moving so the audience would understand that people are being transported in the car?
These are editing choices that have to be taken into consideration when making movies to make what's happening on the screen more cohesive for the people that are watching.
Showing the attack happening right after they allude to it in the movie isn't a case of someone misunderstanding the material, it's reworking it for another medium to show the people that things moved from point A to B.
7
u/RetardTrader420 Aug 23 '26
This.
People fundamentally fail to understand that when adapting comic books to movies
Shit has to change.
For starters movies are a more mainstream product and has to appeal to a more average person who prefers movies to books.
It’s part of the reason Moore himself described Watchmen as “unfilmable.”
In the context of this scene in the graphic novel, it’s right at the end of the penultimate issue.
Ozymandias says his line, we get a quick page of New York being destroyed and then the volume ends.
The final volume then cuts to New York with masses of bodies.
You’ve got this moment as a reader to process what’s happened before moving on.
You can’t replicate that experience and pacing in a film quite the same way.
Film has different strengths than comic books.
I think this particular scene in the movie is fine. It’s adequate at depicting the twist in a way that doesn’t fully diminish the impact.
It comes across as less subtle, but that’s sort of how most movies are compared to the source material.→ More replies (1)62
u/Olgrateful-IW Aug 22 '26
So what do you have in mind? They show us he did it and the have him say the iconic line to an audience who is basically thinking “well duh, we just watched him do it!”.
Thank goodness all good films are strictly chronological with their scenes. /s
→ More replies (10)→ More replies (32)141
u/Gakoknight Aug 22 '26
Ozymandias, especially in the movies, was a bit too overwhelming an antagonist. Leagues above all other opposition physically, save for Doctor Manhattan, and intellectually superior even to him. The entiry story was basically him beating up on low-powered superheroes and coming up with a plan none of them had any hope of stopping at any point. To me at least, it barely feels like a story worth telling. Essentially just a documentary of one person's superiority, devoid of any tension whatsoever.
178
u/Kelnozz Aug 22 '26
I actually enjoyed his portrayal in the Watchmen show; until the literal very end where he gets bonked on the head from behind at least, I thought that took away from his character considerably considering he is supposed to be able to catch bullets because he reflex’s are so sharp.
→ More replies (1)113
u/Ok-Mastodon2420 Aug 22 '26 edited Aug 22 '26
He's also very old and overconfident and has been basically playing at conflict since he was transported by Manhattan. He spent 7 years in a place with no real struggle except what he pretended their was, then another year in a sham trial that he controlled, then was frozen and launched back to earth. The point was that he's well past his prime and not as clever or powerful as he thinks he is.
Edit: to quote the heavy: " Some people think they can outsmart me. Maybe, maybe. I've yet to meet one that can outsmart bullet."
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (19)46
u/Ultgran Aug 22 '26
I would struggle to call Ozymandias the real antagonist of Watchmen. It's a grey-vs-grey morality setting, and the majority of the story in the comic is more about the fight each hero has with themselves.
Really they are mostly all as bad as one another. The Comedian was a state sponsored blackmailer, assassin and war criminal. Rorschach is an explicitly and intentionally bigoted, hyper-violent vigilante, already in the process of self destruction. Dr Manhattan has been losing his humanity since the government used him as a weapon of mass destruction in 'nam. Ozymandias had his plan. All were forced to retire from heroing, but they couldn't stop the root cause of their being heroes.
Nite Owl and Laurie are the most sympathetic characters, but also the least "super".
→ More replies (6)
1.5k
u/Spader113 Aug 22 '26
758
u/Mysral Aug 22 '26
Yup. Honestly, so much of Kingsman qualifies. It's loaded to the brim with ludicrous over-the-top tropes, but executes them damn well.
→ More replies (1)253
u/satantherainbowfairy Aug 22 '26
Just because it executes them well doesn't mean it's playing then straight. The film is a comedy and all the action movie tropes it uses are used as jokes. The fact it actually succeeds is more to do with the fact that the film is just very well made.
149
u/drleebot Aug 22 '26
The amount of comedy is a blurry line. This type of thing was played "straight" in older Bond films, but there was always some amount of tongue-in-cheek for them that they knew they were being ridiculous.
Then the Austin Powers series came out and skewered it all so mercilessly that the Bond writers had to tone it all down, as they didn't feel they were left any space that was less ridiculous than Austin Powers but still amusingly ridiculous. Kingsman proved that wrong, showing that you just had to commit to it. If everyone in the movie takes it seriously, the audience will too, even while they're laughing through it.
25
u/Yung_Bill_98 Aug 23 '26
I wish bond would go back to that. I can't be bothered with another serious "gritty" one
→ More replies (1)5
u/Kedly Aug 23 '26
Eh, I like a broader spread of media in the same category. Saints Row did the same thing to GTA for a while and I really enjoyed GTA 4 for its more serious tone, since Saints Row was providing an avenue of over the top fun chaos.
→ More replies (2)14
u/Shipbreaker_Kurpo Aug 22 '26
the whole villain will monologue bit was played so well because so many of the tripes goes as expected
→ More replies (1)68
u/Pucelage Aug 22 '26
I think this test would have an unnecessarily high number of false positives
Too many guys would realize that the bad guy wouldnt risk his own life to untie them with a train already aproaching and just not tell him bc of that
63
u/Spader113 Aug 22 '26
If I was in that situation, I’d be panicking too much to think with that much logic.
11
u/SergenteA Aug 23 '26
Is it a false positive? Or is it just realising the truth, that no person in their line of work is ever going to free you after getting the information, be it by threatening your life or by torture or whatever.
Plus if one can reason with cold logic like that when under pressure, ditto to them.
They will have other tests and vetting to understand loyalty, it's not like tests are a rigid thing they can't do more of.
→ More replies (2)
2.1k
u/Nirast25 Aug 22 '26
Speaking of tying someone to rails (scene for Venture Bros between Red Death and Blind Rage)

353
u/FishWithLegsAndArms Aug 22 '26
Tick tick tick
→ More replies (1)207
u/Dick_Danalu_Jr Aug 22 '26
Nowadays its all digital: no ticking, no peril.
15
u/xSantenoturtlex Aug 23 '26
Oh! Oh-ho-ho!
Do you hear that? There's the ticking! The train is coming!
9
797
u/Mysral Aug 22 '26
The man's the living embodiment of the saying that the only difference between cliché and classic is execution. And boy does he nail the execution.
229
u/Db_Grimlock Aug 22 '26
I saw some one post about characters that are introduced late in a series but are beloved. Red Death is introduced late but might be my favorite character in a show filled with awesome characters. Also Clancy Brown is a treasure
→ More replies (2)40
u/KaiJustissCW Aug 22 '26
Clancy Brown is great in everything. Detroit Become Human is so damn corny but we LOVE Hank Anderson.
52
u/Afalstein Aug 22 '26
I mean, that's basically this trope in a nutshell. The trope is copied because it was done so well at first, so imitators try to speedrush it without realizing what made the original work, until the imitations come across as silly. Only someone who can truly nail the execution can bring back the original flavor.
→ More replies (1)9
u/SomeBoxofSpoons Aug 23 '26
There's a big difference between something being "vanilla" and something being "original recipie".
131
u/somebeautyinit Aug 22 '26 edited Aug 22 '26
My absolute favorite part is that it's not personal. It's just his job. But boy howdy does love the hell out of his job.
Also, the fan service exchange in the movie where Brock and Shore Leave clearly aren't sure if Brock could take him is both hilarious and humbling.
6
u/GKNolan Aug 23 '26
In this particular case it is personal. This is his final arch. One last hurrah into the frey before he retires from the field and resumes his role as councilman of the Guild. Watch and Ward gave everybody in the council envelopes containing their final arches, personally suited to them. Red Death didn't even look at his. Crumpled it up, threw it in the trash and went right after Blind Rage, who went out of his way to antagonize him in previous episodes.
23
u/Electrical_Catch9231 Aug 22 '26
Came here to state that this is THE example of the tying someone to the rails trope done right. Glad to see I was beat to the punch.
Tick tick tick
68
u/Bionicjoker14 Aug 22 '26
I’ve never watched Venture Bros. This is the only scene I’ve ever seen.
73
30
31
u/Nirast25 Aug 22 '26
First couple of seasons are a little rough, but it gets sooooo good later.
40
u/ThatDeadMoonTitan Aug 22 '26
First half of season one is. Ghosts of Sargasso is where it really picks up and besides 1-2 episodes in season 2 it’s bangers all the way in my opinion. Like Victor Echo November is a 10/10 episodes in S2.
9
u/DengarLives66 Aug 22 '26
I think it’s all relative. The first few episodes are more family focused, but Tag Sale You’re It is a great introduction in terms of establishing the world they live in. The animation and voices are jarring compared to later seasons, and some of the jokes didn’t age well, but overall seasons 1-2 are still very solid.
28
u/HallowskulledHorror Aug 22 '26
Been watching since it was completely new, and my partner and I still get new references out of it, or will be watching/reading something and learn something was a reference. Just watched the David Lynch Dune a while ago, and we both died laughing realizing that 24's "maybe his name is a killing word" was a fuckin' Dune reference this whole time.
8
u/Conscious-Gap-1777 Aug 22 '26
Best part of Season 1 is the "They hit me with a truuuuuucccckkk" scene. I never tire of watching that.
→ More replies (3)16
u/ArcadianBlueRogue Aug 22 '26
Fucking Clancy Brown. Dude has such gravitas when he voices a villain
→ More replies (1)10
u/ProtectionTop2701 Aug 22 '26
Does Blind Rage ever show up in the show after this? I think this was near the end of the series but I think Red Death really did kill him here.
10
22
6
→ More replies (5)16
u/DrugarBurbis Aug 22 '26
Uuuuh is blind rage an idiot to rage bait this guy and immediately get one hit ko’d?
54
u/AsherTheFrost Aug 22 '26
There is a bit going on.
First the organizations behind each.
Red Death is part of the Guild of Calamitous Intent. A once mighty and respected name in villainy, at this point they're in what sports teams call a "rebuilding" year with the death of their leader (right after he had destroyed most of their ruling council) and a renegade hunting some of their top living members.
Blind Rage is part of the Peril Partnership, which has been taking resources and getting defectors from the guild.
Also, what he was demanding, and waiting for was the protection money the guild leadership had decided to give them. So from there, BR thinks he's got the upper hand because he thinks the Guild is worried about what the Partnership will do next
What he didn't count on was that Red Death is an absolute legend.
4
u/DrugarBurbis Aug 22 '26
Thank you for the context, its one if the shows where I actually know nothing about it
→ More replies (3)18
u/Roshenha-Glensfield Aug 22 '26
I mean
"Blind Rage"
His choice of name really didn't imply he had a positive Intelligence score. Maybe a half decent Charisma one for the reference, but yeah. Just a somewhat funny thug with a 'Neat' power.
12
1.1k
u/whoadwoadie Aug 22 '26
The petty, self-obsessed asshole. Usually the domain of Alan from Die Hard-type guys, high school jock bullies, and lower-tier wrestling heels. An annoyance but still a goofball to cheer when given a comeuppance.
Patrick Bateman takes that trope and gives him both the willingness to kill, rape, and torture (maybe) and the time to show how absolutely broken and awful a person like that can be inside. Hell, the Paul murder was because of a damn business card being more tasteful than his!
→ More replies (3)78
1.4k
u/MartyrOfDespair Aug 22 '26

The first Danganronpa uses the classic "evil twin" trope combined with the "person you thought was one twin was actually the other" plot with the mastermind, Junko Enoshima. You likely didn't see it coming because part of what sold it was that she murdered her twin sister in cold blood while she was pretending to be her.
763
u/Zaggar Aug 22 '26
"Hey you look different than in the fashion mags, is that cause-"
"Cause they totally air brush me, yassss. That's it, no other reason. Toodles!"
435
u/izzynk3003 Aug 22 '26
It also works because since it's the first Danganronpa at the very beginning, you most likely won't question why she isn't acting much as Ultimate Fashionista as most other characters do with their respective talents in the franchise
148
u/Zaggar Aug 22 '26
If only the Ultimate Soldier were the Ultimate Infiltrator.
Maybe for the next one, they could sneak in something like that, like an Ultimate Copycat or Ultimate Tabloid-Reader, who can mimic someone famous to such a degree that the characters believe it, but we as the audience are suspicious because they are clearly not that person.
Anyway, I'm excited for 2x2 and really hope we see more of Byakuya
→ More replies (1)18
u/JayedSkier Aug 22 '26
Literally happens in the third game.
→ More replies (1)33
u/Zaggar Aug 22 '26
I was cheekily referring to Byakuya in 2 without even realizing I also could have meant Tsumugi, aw man.
Tsumugi was my favourite for most of V3, but Kokichi & Kaito both took my heart
23
u/TheMilkiestShake Aug 22 '26
Isn't she the first to die too so you don't really spend much time with her anyway
→ More replies (1)10
41
u/EMPTY_SODA_CAN Aug 22 '26
Is it still worth playing these game knowing the twist? Ive seen a bunch of things about it and im interested in playing through them it seems to have a fun cast of characters.
91
u/bananajambam3 Aug 22 '26
Knowing the twists just allows you to see the clever hints layered throughout. It won’t be the same experience but it will still be a fun one.
Personally though I don’t think the character writing really hits its stride until the second game.
24
u/Skylair13 Aug 22 '26
The journey can be as rewarding as the destination.
It's still a game with social links. You can still get to know more about each character before their big moment comes. How that affects you can be unique to you only.
→ More replies (3)5
u/Bentman343 Aug 22 '26
The game was actually very fun to go through knowing that Junko Enoshima is the villain but NOT knowing she has a twin sister, so watching her get impaled in the first hour of the game was a shock and left me guessing the whole rest of the game.
→ More replies (7)17
508
u/Correct_Plant_373 Aug 22 '26
I'm glad someone else appreciates anakin him being simple emotional and unnuanced in his understanding gets memed on buti love it
251
u/IrregularPackage Aug 22 '26
it’s a great delivery and honestly the perfect line. he’s so far gone that the only thing he can think about is how much he hates kenobi now. it gives the impression that he’s clawing at the gravel to keep trying to kill kenobi rather than save his own life.
→ More replies (1)57
116
u/udmurrrt Aug 22 '26
I think Christensen was a bit stiff in some of his line deliveries as Anakin, but damn did he do the dark/ brooding/ hateful stuff well. In any case he didn't deserve the shit he got.
45
u/Electronic-Sea8418 Aug 23 '26
you should research that some more, because the reality ended up being that Lucas was so bad at dialogue across all 6 of his directed SE movies that the original cast routinely corrected him, with Carrie Fisher telling him “George, people don’t talk like this.”
but by the time of the sequels Lucas was such a monolith that people were afraid to correct him and we got deliveries like we see, to no fault of the cast, who wanted to play the scenes differently, but were over ruled by Lucas. Lucas himself has even admitted he “may have gone too far” in some places.
Christensens acting was never the problem, and the poor guy caught hell for it. which is why it’s delightful seeing him reprise the role. in a single episode of Ahsoka he seamlessly code-switches between ROTS Anakin, animated Clone Wars Anakin, and even a Darth Vader persona absent of suit and prosthetics. right down to the freaking combat styles. It was incredible to watch.
10
u/TextDependent6779 Aug 23 '26
What was the line mark strong armed him into removing?
But we can’t turn back, fear is their greatest defense, I doubt if the actual security there is any greater than it was on Aquilae or Sullust and what there is is most likely directed towards a large-scale assault
What the fuck? What did you just say Mark?
Yeah, the big reason the originals are better is because lucas had more people calling him out on his bullshit.
→ More replies (1)7
u/avimo1904 Aug 23 '26
Mark Hamill completely misremembered the story behind that line. The actual line Lucas wrote started with "Luke's got a point" and not "But we can't turn back" and it was for Obi-Wan and not Luke, and it was scrapped before Hamill was even hired cause of budget cuts making Lucas remove the scene it was going to be in. Lucas just had Hamill recite the line as a test
→ More replies (3)5
u/udmurrrt Aug 23 '26
Oh I know Lucas is to blame for the dialogue. But some actors were still better at delivering lines, better at facial expressions etc than others. I suspect Christensen might've seemed a bit wooden even with a great script.
I haven't seen him in any of the new SW stuff, and I'm happy to see the outpouring of love for him - but it could also be that he's just improved his game since the early 2000's :)
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (11)67
1.4k
u/Speed_Vago Aug 22 '26
In the Red Dead Redemption games you can also lay people in the rail traks and then see what happens when the train actually arrives.
1.2k
u/beter-griffin Aug 22 '26
177
Aug 22 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
38
u/name-classified Aug 22 '26
I've watched videos of Arthur leading the goddamn gigantic albino aligator to the camp and watch it just devour everyone!
This game is fucking grim as fuck and hilarious for it
17
88
u/CategoryKiwi Aug 22 '26
almost exclusively the domain of mustache-twirling cartoon scoundrels
OP's comment here lines up perfectly with that achievement icon
50
u/DinosaurReborn Aug 22 '26
Tried it in 2 and was disappointed that it didn't lead to a gory death animation with body parts flying all over.
→ More replies (3)8
u/MilanDespacito Aug 23 '26
Such a weird decision, when it was already in the first game. Despite the improvement in gore, they decided not to add this?
Could it be they couldnt decide how it would look best? With RDR1, bodies exploding fit with its somewhat cartoonish design, but maybe they had difficulties figuring out how to do it for the more realistic one?
72
→ More replies (5)31
u/The_Grand_Briddock Aug 22 '26
I stopped playing that game for a while because I had way too much freedom to do this.
It took me longer than I'll admit to leave the first town because I just kept going to the nearby station and tying people to the tracks.
→ More replies (2)
497
u/Afalstein Aug 22 '26
https://giphy.com/gifs/3VeP43iSJIjJu
Lord of the Rings, Legolas and Gimli
"Never thought I'd die fighting side by side with an elf."
"What about side by side with a friend?"
"Aye, I could do that."
Return of the King is such a beloved classic that I don't think people recognize how much this line should not work. It's campy and sappy, like something out of an 80's tv special. But it does work because it comes at the end of three movies of these two sniping at each other and gradually moving from open hostility to friendly rivalry. It's played straight, and thus it works.
74
u/Soft-Needleworker489 Aug 22 '26
"It's played straight, and thus works." Exactly why Bathos is a problem a lot of the time, when used correctly Bathos can add to a scene, but so often if it had been played straight the scene would've been so much better.
134
38
u/PhoenixApok Aug 22 '26
I'm not even a big LotR guy and this scene can make my throat catch.
It's also about being able to set aside all one's preconceived notions and finally accept the truth for what it is. Sometimes our pasts can blind us to something beautiful that has been right beside us the whole time
→ More replies (1)22
u/Donatien920 Aug 22 '26
I don't think it's campy because it is earned. LOTR was the last bastion of earnest fantasy before superhero movies made everyone quippy and sarcastic.
Seriousness in high budget speculative fiction films is only just now making a comeback with films like Dune and Odyssey.
332
u/scrotbofula Aug 22 '26
Similar to the 3rd example, in the recent Dune, there's the moment where Paul is starting to see visions through exposure to unrefined spice, and yells for someone to help him. It's a great moment, because not only does it show how young and still afraid he is, his mother is literally next to him when he yells it after having pushed her away.
There's something gutwrenching there from both perspectives: a son who is terrified and is begging for help from anyone except his mother; and from her perspective, a mother watching her son go through that while pushing her away.
It should be a stupid cliche line but it's acted with such depth. It's a great moment.
793
u/Jebs1209 Aug 22 '26
The Prestige did the "secret twin" trope better than anything else I've seen or read.
183
→ More replies (41)52
u/beepboopgopoop Aug 22 '26
Big Brother has done the “twin twist” twice (season 5 and season 17)
A set of twins swap out every few days, pretending to be one person. They only have a few minutes while changing in the diary room to exchange information and get up to date on the goings on in the house. In season 17 one of the twins becomes romantically involved with a housemate, which as you can imagine leads to some pretty awkward situations…
35
u/TheMobHasSpoken Aug 22 '26
There was also a very good twin-related task in Taskmaster, series 20.
16
90
u/Bluelore Aug 22 '26
Jonathan Joestar is pretty much your typcial fantasy hero who is such a paragon of righteousness and goodness that it can easily come off as cliche and boring.
What makes it work is that the later parts feature his descendants as main characters and Jonathans righteous personality helps to make his entire bloodline feel like they are good people because of him. Which works especially well due to his tragic death.

It also helps that nowadays the cliche righteous and purely good hero has become so rarely used that by modern standards Jonathan can actually feel like a breath of fresh air again.
→ More replies (1)19
100
u/wimpykidfan37 Aug 22 '26
The Lion King (the original 1994 version) has Simba shouting "NOOOOOOO!" when he watches Mufasa fall into the wildebeest stampede. He manages to pull it off without sounding cheesy. As we found out in Revenge of the Sith, this is something Mufasa himself couldn't do.
→ More replies (2)38
u/Mysral Aug 22 '26
IIRC, the director managed to get Young Simba's actor to do that scream by having him imagining his mom falling. To great effect, as we can see now~!
→ More replies (2)
48
u/Golden12500 Aug 22 '26
The Mask(Comics)
The movie is incredibly silly and is a great example of cartoon physics translated to live action. The comics it's based on however are the exact opposite as it's a freakshit horror series where cartoony effects cause real damage. An anvil falling on your head won't just flatten you like a pancake injury-free, it will crush your fucking skull. He's not even called The Mask in the comics, he's known as the Big Head Killer

176
u/MaleGardev0ir Aug 22 '26
real talk when kuvira was fighting those bandits in that episode i actually thought she was able to control magnets or something. then it was never actually addressed and turns out it was just metalbending, she just attached the metal bands to group up the bandits together
118
u/Lost-on-Reception Aug 22 '26
If you think about it if she can control metal she can control magnets.
36
u/shotgunocelot Aug 22 '26
Like a reverse Magneto
33
u/Lost-on-Reception Aug 22 '26
Since he controls non-ferrous metals it's probably more just a straightforward Magneto.
14
u/Cyberwolf33 Aug 22 '26
There are limitations to which metals they can control in Avatar. TLOK canonizes that platinum can’t be controlled by metal benders as it’s “too pure” for earth bending to affect it.
So a very limited scope Magneto (as we can probably guess that aluminum and titanium are also out, once they are discovered)
→ More replies (4)9
807
u/siennajsi Aug 22 '26
The "I Have Your Family / Hostage Ransom" (The Dark Knight)
In The Dark Knight, the Joker puts Harvey Dent and Rachel in two different warehouses rigged with explosives and forces Batman to choose. Batman races to save them, but the Joker switched the addresses. Batman gets there too late Rachel dies instantly while they’re still on the phone, and Harvey ends up with half his face burned off and his mind completely broken.
203
u/Rock-Facts Aug 22 '26
How is that normally silly?
531
u/siennajsi Aug 22 '26
The old hostage trope always felt kind of silly because movies and TV turned it into this predictable game where the hero always saves everyone at the last second with no real consequences.The Dark Knight flipped it and made it actually terrifying. It showed the obvious truth: a sadistic terrorist isn’t going to play fair, even a superhero can’t just ignore distance and time, and yeah… someone actually dies.
67
u/Wundercheese Aug 22 '26
Compare this sequence to Batman Forever, where the Riddler tries to make Batman choose between saving his love interest and Robin, and of course he manages to save both.
166
u/deathbunny32 Aug 22 '26
Its also referencing when joker tells batman to not hit the suspect in the head as they can get all mixed up and confused
→ More replies (1)44
→ More replies (1)16
Aug 22 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
39
5
u/thejokerofunfic Aug 22 '26
Depends on the context. In something like Batman? Many viewers would think of it as "when", not "if", Bruce figures out how to save everyone from the deathtrap. Hostage situation in superhero media usually meant the drama only went as far as "how will he pull this off" but there was always some convenient way to simply save the hostage other than doing what the villain wants. Anyone raised on old Batman cartoons would have expected that. Anyone who'd seen Spider-Man 2002 would have expected that since it literally has the same sadistic choice and Pete still saves both choices.
If this was like, a Scoresese crime drama and not Batman, then yes, a hostage situation is high stakes, but for audiences going into superhero films when TDK came out it was just a standard cliche scenario for those, barely removed from the "tied to train tracks" idea.
30
u/FarutaSarado Aug 24 '26
"Success doesn't come for free, you have to do whatever it takes to seize your moment" - Ernesto Dela Cruz (Coco)
When he first says it, the quote sounds like a corny inspirational line meant to tell people to follow their dreams.
Later on, the audience finds out that when he said "whatever it takes", he literally means murder.

82
u/theDaemon0 Aug 22 '26
Cesar doing the shouting "no!" in Planet of the Apes. A bit cliché, sure, but if you think about it, it showcases that this isn't just some smarter-than-average ape: not only did he learn how to speak without anyone teaching him how, but he did so with a completely different mouth structure, meaning he couldn't have learned it just from watching humans.
My Hero Academia: the whole show has as its main concept taking certain tropes and powers from hero fiction and asking, "what would the real implications be?". The very first episode has the narration say that humanity would've likely explored space by then, if powers didn't come into being - since that was a whole societal MESS; it then elaborates on things such as, "if a power is to shoot something, where would the physical stuff come from, or wwhat would the effect of this energy type being expelled directly from the body be?", or "a hero's proffession isn't just to curb crime, but to be an inspiring symbol that makes people feel safe - so for them to be allowed to kill would completely ruin that". Even one that can be compared to Rocky: "the human body was never meant for continuous, awe-inspiring heroics; pushing beyond your limits might seem epic, but it WILL have consequences and they'll pile up over the years".
17
u/Thebaldsasquatch Aug 22 '26
That “NO!” Gave me goosebumps. There was SO much power behind it. Andy Serkis is going to go down in history as one of if not THE greatest character actor of all time.
→ More replies (1)27
u/Redditer51 Aug 22 '26
"the human body was never meant for continuous, awe-inspiring heroics; pushing beyond your limits might seem epic, but it WILL have consequences and they'll pile up over the years".
A lot of boxing manga show the really tragic consequences of this. Especially Ashita No Joe.
→ More replies (2)13
u/ballistic503 Aug 22 '26
I watched a BTS thing for The Boys and I’m almost positive that Caesar’s “no” was basically the stage direction for Kimiko speaking for the first time as Frenchie got dragged off to the concentration camp
26
u/Glittering-War-8360 Aug 23 '26
Kuvira’s railway scene works because she isn’t doing it for theatrical villain points, she’s treating human beings like an administrative problem to be disposed of. The maglev makes the whole thing feel brutally modern too, like the world’s least whimsical version of a cartoon death trap. And Anakin yelling “I hate you!” is devastating precisely because it sounds childish. He’s emotionally regressed to the hurt kid underneath all that armor, which makes the scene so much uglier than a cooler, more restrained betrayal speech would’ve been.
→ More replies (1)
120
u/jayswag707 Aug 22 '26
Another great example of light playing off people's faces is in the Force Awakens when Kylo Ren faces Han Solo on the bridge. You can see his internal struggle on whether he should come back to the light or kill his father to cement his journey to the dark side in the blue and red light on his face. Great scene.
→ More replies (4)106
u/Mysral Aug 22 '26
The Sequel Trilogy is full of questionable choices and poor writing, but hot damn does the cinematography hit home.
→ More replies (2)44
u/jayswag707 Aug 22 '26
Yeah, there are individual moments that are just incredible.
I also love Poe Damoran's second introduction in The Force Awakens when he takes out like nine Tie fighters in 11 seconds. It is just so unbearably cool.
→ More replies (1)10
u/Odaik Aug 22 '26
This is the most hype moment of aerial fight in all of the star wars. Hell, in all cinema even.
4
u/jayswag707 Aug 22 '26
It hit a note of awesomeness that you usually only get in the Star Wars video games. It was so freaking cool.
→ More replies (2)
20
u/Acceptable_Egg5560 Aug 23 '26

Red Death from Venture Bros. He also ties a man to a train track, and then monologues to him while the train approaches. While this would be seen as cliche, he shows just how terrifying being tied to a train track would be and also show how monologuing means the villain is in complete control of the situation.
350
u/Borbbb Aug 22 '26
55
→ More replies (2)37
17
u/SpyX2 Aug 22 '26
Sir, You Are Being Hunted is a silly concept, but if you've actually played it, you know it's genuinely terrifying to see the fancy British robots running towards you with their rifles out.
35
u/Dark-Specter Aug 23 '26
Revenge of the sith is such an anomaly. Endlessly impressive that one lightsaber fight start with the standard dogshit prequel dialogue and ends with some of the best performances in the entire trilogy.
28
u/Hydra_Flatline Aug 23 '26
Obi wans bit where he says “you were the chosen one” seems like it shouldn’t work on paper but somehow overcomes the cheesiness. Ewan McGregor really delivers there it seems.
Also when Anakin yells the “I hate you” line, you can see phlegm spray out of his mouth. That’s some real emoting there lol.
→ More replies (1)9
u/TextDependent6779 Aug 23 '26
I reference it often, but there's a fantastic video on YouTube about the camp'ness of the prequels.
It mostly focuses on Ian mcdiarmids performance, but also talks about Ewan McGregor, and slightly touches on Christopher Lee.
Basically, all of these guys know when to play it up and lean into the operatic tone, but also know when to take a step back and perform softer.
It's why these 3 make the material work, when even people like Samuel L Jackson and Natalie Portman struggle.
40
u/justagenericname213 Aug 22 '26
The inner demon trope is pretty common, the evil monster sealed inside someone and it just needs a friend to learn how to be good. And usually it feels pretty silly, this monster that would slaughter hundreds of people without a second thought just needs it's living prison and warden to show it a bit of kindness and everything gets better.
And then theres Ryomen Sukuna laughing at his vessel having a mental breakdown over watching his friend die.

210
u/AmazingLeek69 Aug 22 '26
That whole final scene of that Star Wars movie was so good. Both actors really sold the emotion behind it.
→ More replies (1)
31
u/PurplePolynaut Aug 22 '26
And then Obi-wan following up with “you were my brother, Anakin, I loved you” really twists the knife
13
u/Afalstein Aug 22 '26
Justified has this in spades--the whole show is about a US Marshal who wears a cowboy hat in Kentucky and tends to shoot people, so a lot of it is just playing off silly Western tropes and making them real. But the best moment is probably in the very first episode.

Deputy Marshal Raylan Givens tracks down a bad man in Miami and sits down next to him at a public hotel pool, reminding him that he gave him 24 hours to get out of town or he'd shoot him on sight. As the gun thug points out, that's silly. Police aren't allowed to "shoot people on sight" anymore, for obvious reasons, and they aren't allowed to threaten them saying they have "24 hours" to clear out. The whole thing is a ridiculous wild west setup. Raylan's entire ultimatum makes no sense, there's no way a cop would shoot a (presumably) unarmed man at a public pool in front of thousands of people.
Right?
RIGHT?
8
u/KaiTheG4mer Aug 23 '26
Re Adrian Toomes' realization: it helps too that Vulture's color motif generally in most of the comics is green-heavy
97
u/Beginning_Gift2228 Aug 22 '26
I always took the light bulb moment as peters moment for recognising him with the green glow, never even thought about it that way maybe I'm just dumb
126
u/Visible-Air-2359 Aug 22 '26
Peter knew who he was the moment he appears since the Vulture lost his mask in the fight.
21
u/Beginning_Gift2228 Aug 22 '26
Damn, haven't seen the movie in quite awhile but now I think of it there was a scene in his house when he answered the door i think
12
u/really_stupidfrog Aug 22 '26
Yeah when he answers the door it's a shock to Peter and the audience that the Vulture is his date' dad, but Pete knows as soon as he sees him.
9
u/TheBrownWelsh Aug 23 '26
That scene is so good because there's no build up, no slow motion, no music - Toomes just unceremoniously answers the door as a friendly dad and Peter shits himself.
Side note; my 9yr old kid guessed he was Peter's crush's dad earlier on based on literally nothing, so the surprise didn't hit as hard. And they did it again when we then immediately watched Far From Home in the very first scene with an "Elemental", guessing that someone was creating/controlling the monsters. It was fucking infuriating because they were literally wild guesses but now my kid thinks they're a genius.
→ More replies (1)
9
6
u/BeGentle1mNewHere Aug 23 '26
Joker's laughing gas. What a silly weapon.
But in Mask of the Phantasm and Batman Beyond Return of the Joker, seeing someone laugh uncontrollably until death is fucking terrifying.
11
u/samtherat6 Aug 22 '26
Lol see three results in a row for The Dark Knight, American Psycho, and The Prestige. Guess Christian Bale is a trend breaker.
187
u/_whatever_wherever Aug 22 '26
Naa, in Revenge it totally came off like a screaming child having a temper tantrum
Which was basically Anakin's entire character in those films
"I'm special so should be able to do what I want"
312
u/Sporelord1079 Aug 22 '26
It’s both. The tragedy of Anakin is that he’s is functionally a teenager failed by the parental figures in his life. You can draw a very ugly comparison between Palpatine luring him to the dark side and child grooming.
72
u/thatshygirl06 Aug 22 '26
Just wanna say, not all grooming is sexual. People can be groomed for a certain role
16
12
u/Redditer51 Aug 22 '26
And like a lot of groomers, Palpatine was someone he trusted. Someone who made him feel understood as a way to more easily manipulate him.
66
u/Nothos927 Aug 22 '26
Thing is, really this should be a much more common problem in Star Wars lore than it seemingly is.
Snatch kids from their families at a young age, denying them vital developmental needs and teaching them that they’re special and that normal emotions just get in the way.
The fact that the order isn’t stacked top to bottom with emotionally stunted narcissists is a miracle.
25
u/Lapidations Aug 22 '26
The real problem is that all other media surrounding that movie makes it seem unearned and forced. Watching the Clone Wars show they try to foreshadow it but when you place them side by side it just doesn't work. I'm of the opinion that the prequels all suck and should have just been cartoons like Clone Wars. It would have been easier to do the things that needed to be done. The tone would have fit better. There's all these Jedi doing insane shit and it either looks hokey/campy/lame with live action people. Given how much of those movies were just a green screen anyway, why bother with the live action at all?
41
u/Nothos927 Aug 22 '26
Honestly I think part of the reason the prequels have a much better rep these days isn’t just pure nostalgia but the supplementary media like clone wars smoothed over a lot of the cracks in the story that the films left.
→ More replies (7)→ More replies (4)4
u/OperativePiGuy Aug 22 '26
Completely agreed. I really wish animation was used for more stuff despite the cost because so many more things can be done with it and make it look way less cheesy/campy
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (34)30
u/AcceptableReview3846 Aug 22 '26
Yeah I thought it fit because Anakin is an immature child that has no control of his emotions
42
u/stinkingyeti Aug 22 '26
Not sure I'd call effective use of lighting a silly trope.
→ More replies (1)99
u/Mysral Aug 22 '26
Oh, I agree that it's effective use of lighting. The silly part is that it's basically a live-action idea lightbulb, a la cartoons and comics.
→ More replies (1)












649
u/misterjive Aug 22 '26
In Galaxy Quest, classically trained actor Alexander Dane is absolutely sick to death of being chained to his Dr. Lazarus character from the show, especially his scenery-chewing catchphrase: "By Grabthar's Hammer, by the suns of Warvan, you shall be avenged!" He flips out on the fans that quote it to him endlessly, and delivers a variation of it hatefully at an in-store appearance. It's made so much worse when he meets Quellek, one of the Thermians who think the show was real, and who has modeled his entire life after Dr. Lazarus.
When they're trying to save the ship and crew, Dane meets up with Quellek again, and they work together to save the Thermians. But Quellek is shot, and as he lies dying, Dane delivers the line with all the gravitas it deserves, giving the dying alien comfort in his last moments.
He then goes completely apeshit berserk and beats Quellek's killer to death with his bare hands, delivering on the promise of vengeance.