r/gachagaming • • 7h ago

General Gacha Revenue Monthly Report (September 2026)

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

3.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

74

u/Ecstatic_Judge_4996 6h ago

Because the ones complaining are 99% f2p or light spenders being loud. Although the complaints are valid it won't do anything

26

u/cid01 5h ago

All i can say is that the kind of people you find in reddit or twitter are not representative of the overall player base. Not even close. The average player p2p or not didnt even know about the recent outrage.

14

u/TheGuyThatDoesStuff1 Main: HSR Sub: AK/FGO/HI3 5h ago

How have to be a very specific minority of player to have an opinion about the "issues" in HSR, you have to be either a F2P who is really deep in the game and doesn't just play casually or a P2P with so much expendable income that you spend without liking the core game. Most F2P are too casual, and despite what many think a lot of P2P can only afford to spend on a game they genuinelly like.

16

u/PatheticAndTragic HSR 5h ago

I don't think light spenders are complaining, I'm a monthly pass buyer and I still just brain off auto full star end game

I feel its mostly F2P players who pull very horizontally having a hard time

•

u/Tetrachrome 1h ago

Personally I stopped light spending, because I realized I'm just exchanging money for numerical power and not actually enjoying the game more.

•

u/YannFrost 3h ago

This is true, but even f2p players who plays the endgame won't quit, because endgame is endgame. It isn't the whole game. We enjoy other stuff beside the endgame, like the story and characters.

It is a very quick game to play. I do not care if I miss 300 jades every few months.

•

u/Exolve708 2h ago

Problem is you need to do both horizontal and vertical now. The only reason I'm struggling with this PF is because I didn't pick the archetypes that are shilled this cycle. I have 4 6-7 cost teams with sig LCs and no E2s, but only 2 of them have buffs so I'm at like 26k on the third one. On top of that even the flagship Ela team is kinda ass, SW with premium members and LCs only did 32-33k when the Rem team during Amph got 40k every time in 2 cycles max with the same investment. (This was before Pearl, haven't tried with her yet.)

This PF is just way overtuned, it knocked everyone down a tier in general. I also saw a bunch of people complain about their scores with E2S1 DPSs dropping to my older 4.x scores from their comfy 40k clears.

Not that it really matters, but this is the reason I don't even get the monthly/pass in HSR. In other games they get me a 90%+ collection and comfy endgames, in HSR I could get like 2 of my DPSs to E2 each year and that's it lmao.

•

u/tyranthym 1h ago edited 1h ago

No even as to 4.6. for any F2P the only right way to play is pull horizontally. E2 is for spender not even an option for f2p to beat all endgames. the complainers are ppl only login once every year or quit for 2 years and come back but somehow thinking they should still clear all endgames lol

3

u/Rain-Maker33 Paimon | Mem | ZOOT P̷R̷T̷S̷ 5h ago

In the HSR sub, I think the loudest people tend to be people who also natter on about vertical investment and pulling E2S1.

Well, the powercreep and HP inflation stuff is real, though.

8

u/MenmaOnyx 5h ago

actual complaints clearly did something with lads, meaning most hoyo complaints are hollow, since rarely anything happnes with it

17

u/Pitiful-Assignment-8 5h ago

Correct, because the LADS situation affected not the loud minority, but the most dangerous thing - the quiet majority.

The current HSR situation affects literally a certain layer of meta slaves, who scream that they can't clear some content for one reason or another.
Not only is this a minority, but this situation doesn't affect Whales and the majority at all, who don't really experience FOMO about endgame.

•

u/Tetrachrome 1h ago

I mean this isn't much of a surprise though, we all know the spending curve isn't distributed across the playerbase, you could delete 95% of any gacha game's playerbase and the revenue number wouldn't budge because the last 5% are the whales dropping easily 1000x more per month than most players would ever spend in the entire game's lifetime.

6

u/HamzaW66 5h ago

Like all those complainer are type of people who just does not want to put effort into game, they think just cuz elation is being shilled there is no way f2p could clear with e0s0 which is straight up lie, I only pulled aglaea, the herta, phainon e0s0 in 3.x when remembrance was being shilled but I still manage to clear all endgames with these units, and with sustain like fu Xuan and Loucha like fr, when people were saying you absolutely need hyacine if you want to surive, I just skipped her and did not faced any problem, only if that loud minority can put same effort into game they will finally understand they don't need full e2s1 teams to clear normal endgames.

3

u/sloppyloki16 5h ago

im f2p and max star everything since loucha banner in 1.2 , more than f2p they just bad at games, because hsr (and most gachas) are braindead easy , you have to try hard to not beat endgame with the available reosurces

while the complains have real basis to stand on hp inflation is real (and is increaisng pretty fats lately) and powercreep also real, tho in the 1,x to 2.x era was wya bigger woth acheron doing 3 or 4 more times damage than dan il or jingliu, nowdays elation etams dont do 3 tiemes more damage than a rem team at all so powercreep is pretty tame compared to the past

hsr, zzz, nte, wuwa are all easy af to keep up as f2p to do all endgame (i say those because are the oens i played for long tho i quit wuwa and nte not so long ago) so i have to assume most gachas are eays af

•

u/YuesaSR HSR x4 | Windmeet | Arknight | LOTM | Snowbreak | Browndust2 3h ago

hsr is like 30% difficulty + powercreep of all gachas i have played (i play 15 years of gachas)

its just f2p + casual struggled

real top up casual just rolled content because they e2 their favorite char